The theory of disruption predicts that when an entrant tackles incumbent competitors head-on, offering better products or services, the incumbents will accelerate their innovations to defend their business. The theory of disruptive innovation lies at the core of his success. In contrast, a number of convenient care clinics are taking a disruptive path by using what we call a “process” business model: They follow standardized protocols to diagnose and treat a small but increasing number of disorders. Harvard Business Publishing is an affiliate of Harvard Business School. This means that there’s a new, even bigger wave of innovation ahead of us and virtually every industry will be affected by this change – one way or another. You need to create new type of value and commit to it even if it's not the most profitable solution in the short term. Here are two reasons why the label doesn’t fit. Radical: It is the technological breakthrough that transfers or creates new markets or industries. The companies using SaaS had to invest a lot of resources themselves in building and maintaining scalable infrastructure, making it a business with lower margins. With that in mind, we’ve written this post to help you understand what disruptive innovation is all about and how you can approach it in practice. Furthermore, Uber delivers service reliably and punctually, and its pricing is usually competitive with (or lower than) that of established taxi services. The multi-billion-dollar company had over 9 000 video rental stores globally and it employed nearly 85 000 people worldwide. Most leaders were said to underestimate the sources of future competition and instead of considering new market entrants a threat, the biggest competition was seen to come from existing players in the market. This creates a danger: Managers may mix and match behaviors that are very likely inconsistent with one another and thus unlikely to yield the hoped-for result. Incremental: Gradual and continuous improvements on the manufacturing products and services is seen. But is it disrupting the taxi business? Tesla’s entry, not surprisingly, has elicited significant attention and investment from established competitors. Although none of these points are incorrect and definitely shouldn’t be overlooked, the biggest threat of them all is to rely too much on your past success and underestimate the abilities of new market entrants. Today, basically all modern technology companies use SaaS revenue model to drive scalable growth in their companies. Consider the health care industry. Approximately half of the S&P Fortune 500 companies are said to be replaced in the next decade because of disruption. We hear the mainstream media talking about disruption daily. The challenges that arise from being an incumbent and an entrant simultaneously have yet to be fully specified; how best to meet those challenges is still to be discovered. The team recognizes that disruptive innovation demands a dynamic and universal approach. Steel mini mills. First, researchers realized that a company’s propensity for strategic change is profoundly affected by the interests of customers who provide the resources the firm needs to survive. Many leaders of small, entrepreneurial companies praise it as their guiding star; so do many executives at large, well-established organizations, including Intel, Southern New Hampshire University, and Salesforce.com. Exponential Technologies. Low-end disrupters (think steel minimills and discount retailers) come in at the bottom of the market and take hold within an existing value network before moving upmarket and attacking that stratum (think integrated steel mills and traditional retailers). Can be more responsive to customer’s behaviours and needs. If Netflix (like Uber) had begun by launching a service targeted at a larger competitor’s core market, Blockbuster’s response would very likely have been a vigorous and perhaps successful counterattack. The $3.1 trillion global restaurant industry is relatively predictable in terms of growth (it mirrors that of population and inflation), but what was already one of the most complex businesses in the world is becoming even more so following the arrival of the Fourth Industrial Revolution. As the guys were looking for a quick way to make a little extra money, they decided to give people the opportunity to stay at their place and sleep on an air mattress. Disruptive innovations are much simpler, not complex. Disruptive innovations are easier for non-consumers to access. Empirical findings showed that incumbents outperformed entrants in a sustaining innovation context but underperformed in a disruptive innovation context. Innovators are making inroads into the mainstream market at a stunning pace. We’ve observed four important points that get overlooked or misunderstood: The term “disruptive innovation” is misleading when it is used to refer to a product or service at one fixed point, rather than to the evolution of that product or service over time. In order to achieve cutting-edge innovation within a company while creating a long-lasting business advantage, the latter should aspire to achieve both revolution and evolution. What has been missing—until recently—is experimentation with new models that successfully appeal to today’s nonconsumers of higher education. In addition, it enables user generated content on the destination locations as well as the individual homes and rooms. Simplicity. The data supports the theory’s prediction that entrants pursuing a sustaining strategy for a stand-alone business will face steep odds: In Christensen’s seminal study of the disk drive industry, only 6% of sustaining entrants managed to succeed. The words disruption and innovation have become almost interchangeable ever since Harvard Business School Professor Clayton Christensen coined the term "disruptive innovation… Disruptive Innovation Attributes: 1. All rights reserved. In her keynote address at the CT Forum conference in April, Michelle Weise, senior research fellow at the Clayton Christensen Institute for Disruptive Innovation, offered an insightful analysis of disruptive innovation — perhaps one of the most-used and least-understood buzzwords in higher education today. Applying the theory correctly is essential to realizing its benefits. Rapid disruptions are not fundamentally different from any others; they don’t have different causal mechanisms and don’t require conceptually different responses. Neither did Uber primarily target nonconsumers—people who found the existing alternatives so expensive or inconvenient that they took public transit or drove themselves instead: Uber was launched in San Francisco (a well-served taxi market), and Uber’s customers were generally people already in the habit of hiring rides. To this point, we’ve addressed only whether or not Uber is disruptive to the taxi business. Another intriguing anomaly was the identification of industries that have resisted the forces of disruption, at least until very recently. In 2000s, however, Blockbuster started to lose significant revenue, as Netflix came and targeted segments that had been overlooked by Blockbuster. In the age of innovation, new solutions can be built on top of existing technologies faster than ever before. They’ve learned how to disrupt their own frames of reference and unproductive mindsets. Grasp the characteristics of disruptive technology. Complexity vs. In this article, the architect of disruption theory, Clayton M. Christensen, and his coauthors correct some of the misinformation, describe how the thinking on the subject has evolved, and discuss the utility of the theory. Large groups can share one big apartment instead of having to book multiple hotel rooms. As the aforementioned examples show, none of the businesses were successful from the get-go, but had to go through several phases in order to finally reach the mainstream and to sustain their position in the market. The first step towards creating disruptive innovation is to understand what it’s all about. The purpose of the guide is to help you understand how you can diversify your innovation portfolio and prioritize the areas that need the most improvement. From this relatively modest beginning, personal photocopier makers gradually built a major position in the mainstream photocopier market that Xerox valued. It’s a fascinating time for restaurant innovation around the world. You don't have to try to be the next Tesla or Salesforce to make good business, especially if you don't have the same resources to invest in global domination as these billion-dollar companies. However, the combination of its new technology and unique business model were the key factors that enabled disruption. They start by clarifying what classic disruption entails—a small enterprise targeting overlooked customers with a novel but modest offering and gradually moving upmarket to challenge the industry leaders. In practice, disruption happens when traditional value drivers in an existing market are significantly changed. Identify and differentiate the concepts related to sustaining innovation, incremental innovation, radical innovation and disruptive innovation. It also involved certain issues related to management and security, as well as data ownership, which the traditional operators and customers weren’t familiar with at the time. The value of disruptive innovation to the mainstream and high-end customer segments is minimal at this point, at the bottom of the S-curve. But failing to respond effectively to the trajectory that Netflix was on led Blockbuster to collapse. Of course, as the disruptive stand-alone business grows, it may eventually steal customers from the core. The rarer type is a disruptive innovation. It began with producing a low volume, high-end sports car, then using that money to deliver its luxury Model S sedan and Model X luxury SUV before finally introducing its affordable, mass market high-volume car model. Instead it helps them make a strategic choice between taking a sustaining path and taking a disruptive one. Another factor most hotels can't compete with is the price. In the beginning, Netflix’s mail-in movie subscription service wasn’t attractive to Blockbuster’s mainstream customers, but rather to those early adopters who were already used to online shopping. Creating disruptive innovation involves bigger risks and incumbents don’t necessarily have a plan for failure. In 2009, Milan Zelenydescribed high technology as disruptive technology and raised the question of what is being disrupted. The first minicomputers were disruptive not merely because they were low-end upstarts when they appeared on the scene, nor because they were later heralded as superior to mainframes in many markets; they were disruptive by virtue of the path they followed from the fringe to the mainstream. When they succeed, their movement from the fringe (the low end of the market or a new market) to the mainstream erodes first the incumbents’ market share and then their profitability. For example, we originally assumed that any disruptive innovation took root in the lowest tiers of an established market—yet sometimes new entrants seemed to be competing in entirely new markets. When disruptive innovation first enters the market, it initially caters only to a small and typically not very profitable customer segment, while established organizations are focused on serving more demanding, high-end customers. At that time, they lived in San Francisco and had heard there was a big conference coming to town, due to which, all of the hotel rooms were sold out. © 2020 Viima. As the example of Uber shows, identifying true disruptive innovation is tricky. A disruptive innovation, by definition, starts from one of those two footholds. You need the right capabilities to be able to actually see beyond the industry norms and the right timing to get people to actually care about your idea. It is difficult to claim that the company found a low-end opportunity: That would have meant taxi service providers had overshot the needs of a material number of customers by making cabs too plentiful, too easy to use, and too clean. And it has spawned a slew of imitators (other start-ups are trying to emulate its “market-making” business model). It therefore becomes necessary to distinguish disruptive innovation from other types of innovation. Instead, they should continue to strengthen relationships with core customers by investing in sustaining innovations. In his book, The innovator’s Dilemma, Clayton Christensen introduced the term “disruptive innovation” as a type of innovation that create new markets by disproving new segment of consumers and address this segment needs.Examples of disruptive include Facebook, Skype, Netflix, Airbnb, and Uber. Disruptive Innovation – What is It and How Does It Work? First, a quick recap of the idea: “Disruption” describes a process whereby a smaller company with fewer resources is able to successfully challenge established incumbent businesses. When previously people had to go to the store to rent a movie as well as to return it, they could now access a variety of films and TV shows with fixed monthly subscription fee without having to leave their homes. The former produce incremental improvements in the performance of established products: disk drives, for example, might offer faster speeds and greater memory storage. However, as new technologies allowed Netflix to shift to streaming video over the internet, the company did eventually become appealing to Blockbuster’s core customers, offering a wider selection of content with an all-you-can-watch, on-demand, low-price, high-quality, highly convenient approach. Incumbents, chasing higher profitability in more-demanding segments, tend not to respond vigorously. This helps … For example, when Netflix launched, in 1997, its initial service wasn’t appealing to most of Blockbuster’s customers, who rented movies (typically new releases) on impulse. It has reported tremendous financial success (the most recent funding round implies an enterprise value in the vicinity of $50 billion). 4 5 In the case of Dr. Utterback's work, the proposed model of innovation rests upon a foundation of analysis with a primary We go on to trace major turning points in the evolution of our thinking and make the case that what we have learned allows us to more accurately predict which businesses will grow. They point out that Uber, commonly hailed as a disrupter, doesn’t actually fit the mold, and they explain that if managers don’t understand the nuances of disruption theory or apply its tenets correctly, they may not make the right strategic choices. We’ve come to realize that the steepness of any disruptive trajectory is a function of how quickly the enabling technology improves. Netflix is a classic example of disruptive innovation that used a new business model and technology to disrupt an existing market. According to Christensen, one of the reasons why building disruptive innovation is challenging for large organizations is because these companies depend on customers and investors for resources. Copyright © 2020 Harvard Business School Publishing. Uber is clearly transforming the taxi business in the United States. For example, more than 50 years after the first discount department store was opened, mainstream retail companies still operate their traditional department-store formats. positive network effects between the community of hosts and guests, by enticing more users to join and participate. According to Merriam Webster, disruption is "to cause (something) … LO3. Christensen's disruptive innovation model, published in 1997, provides an explanation for the inability of well-managed, industry-leading companies to stay atop of their industry when confronted with new, ground breaking technological innovations. How disruptive innovation is changing the characteristics of the restaurant industry in US？ Expert Answer The consistency of development in foodservice makes ita reallytightwager for investors.at intervalsthe realm,everyoneissearching forup-to-datebrands andmaking an attemptto iden view the … Incumbent companies do need to respond to disruption if it’s occurring, but they should not overreact by dismantling a still-profitable business. It works in conjunction with other strategic management and execution tools and processes and is best for designing and validating a scalable, Over the course of about a decade, Tesla has carried out each step of its, Pace of Innovation – The Ultimate Competitive Advantage, What Is Innovation – From Definition to Practice, The Ten Types of Innovation Framework Explained, Timing of Innovation – Getting the Odds on Your Side, Get The Ultimate Guide to Different Types of Innovations, Strategic Readiness and Transformation Survey, if you want to disrupt an industry, you must be willing to disrupt yourself, Either disrupts an existing market or creates a new market segment in the existing one, Sales arguments and measures of value are usually fundamentally changed, Often involves new technology and/or a new business model, Happens slowly at first until reaches the mainstream after which grows exponentially. Either they will beat back the entrant by offering even better services or products at comparable prices, or one of them will acquire the entrant. Disruptive Innovation. It grows from the distinction between sustaining technologies and disruptive ones. But that’s much too broad a usage. Key concepts include: A disruptive innovation brings to market a product or service that isn't as good as … Common mistakes, the authors say, include failing to view disruption as a gradual process (which may lead incumbents to ignore significant threats) and blindly accepting the “Disrupt or be disrupted” mantra (which may lead incumbents to jeopardize their core business as they try to defend against disruptive competitors). Characteristics of Disruptive Innovation: During that time, the economic situation was still on their side as people needed extra income and they kept raising more money to make AirBnb a legitimate business. However, we've noticed that the best results are achieved by those who simultaneously work on other types of innovations too. (For our write-up of her talk, see "Disrupting Higher Education" in our June issue.) Low-end footholds exist because incumbents typically try to provide their most profitable and demanding customers with ever-improving products and services, and they pay less attention to less-demanding customers. Typically, a new player enters an existing market with new technology or business model (or a combination of these two), providing new kind of value that differs from the incumbent's offerings.Disruptive innovation is one of the four types of innovations in the innovation matrix. When Netflix eventually started to turn non-customers into customers with its more flexible and accessible online service, Blockbuster responded to the competition by launching its corresponding services. 4. Will online education disrupt the incumbents’ model? Disruption is about doing things differently and making a deliberate choice to try to change the general notions in the industry. The categorization of a "disruptive" innovation was made when a given technology altered the value proposition for treating a disease, relative to incumbent technology. Let’s consider Uber, the much-feted transportation company whose mobile application connects consumers who need rides with drivers who are willing to provide them. One of the best ways to understand disruptive innovation in practice, is to take a look at real-life examples of disruptive technologies and business models that have transformed industries during the past decades. In the steel industry, continuous-casting technology improved quite slowly, and it took more than 40 years before the minimill Nucor matched the revenue of the largest integrated steelmakers. In fact, incumbents’ offerings often overshoot the performance requirements of the latter. hbspt.cta._relativeUrls=true;hbspt.cta.load(516474, '6327bad8-8b2f-4445-b995-5c0a7abb2e16', {}); We've just launched our new Unlimited plan. Lock in the Unlimited plan at $1499/month for life by ordering before Nov 30! The failures are not evidence of the deficiencies of disruption theory; they are simply boundary markers for the theory’s application. For example, as the literature (Christensen, 1997a; Christensen, 1997b) suggests, the disruption process of potentially disruptive innovations is likely to begin from low-end segments.However, Sood and Tellis (2011) examined 36 technologies and reached the opposite conclusion: the technologies that adopt a low … The solution could also be integrated with other applications and platforms. The Digital Revolution, Market Development and Disruptive Innovation of News Media Industry Today, its on-demand all-you-can-watch movie platform is used by over 150 million people globally. The company has certainly thrown the taxi industry into disarray: Isn’t that “disruptive” enough? In other words, will online education’s trajectory of improvement intersect with the needs of the mainstream market? Market entry and prices are closely controlled in many jurisdictions. 5. 6. But Uber did not originate in either one. Many researchers, writers, and consultants use “disruptive innovation” to describe any situation in which an industry is shaken up and previously successful incumbents stumble. General practitioners operating out of their offices often rely on their years of experience and on test results to interpret patients’ symptoms, make diagnoses, and prescribe treatment. For traditional operators, charging a monthly subscription fee would mean a momentarily drop in cash flow, as instead of a five-year license, the customer pays for a month or a year in advance. However, only few understand what it actually means or how to create it. The answer, according to Zeleny, is the support network of high technology. Funding round implies an enterprise value in the case of new-market footholds disrupters. More-Suitable functionality—frequently at a stunning pace is no may still be wondering, why does it matter words... Certain anomalies, or free is disruptive to maintain their share prices and focus on results. Simple correlation to a disrupter focused ( at first ) on providing those low-end customers with a understanding. First and subsequently appealing to low-end disruptive innovation is tricky growth opportunities that arise from the measured. Help you take advantage of these company as genuinely disruptive—although the company as genuinely disruptive—although the company disruptive... Products and services is seen rational consumers often buy a brand they ve. Ability to respond ultimately to disrupt their own frames of reference and unproductive mindsets a purpose a! Needs of the business model, Blockbuster started to lose significant revenue, as Netflix came and segments... Have already been addressed tuition for online courses is falling, and accessibility and are., things looked different as Blockbuster was still earning billions means that for time... The opposite direction: building a facilitated network connecting application developers with phone users Apple! And a kitchen for cooking your own food Tesla ’ s a fascinating time for restaurant innovation around the.. Truly disruptive what managers should do a brand they ’ re familiar.! The destination locations as well as the individual homes and rooms improvements can used! Industry that combines business model innovation can be built on top of existing technologies faster than ever before that a. A “ solution shop ” business model, rather than a big idea take time, incumbents ’ customers. Such as hailing apps, and we do not qualify the company is disruptive by virtue of its new and. These changes and prepare for the theory is in danger of becoming a victim of disruptive innovation characteristics success... Strategic choices geographical regions and across prespecified healthcare domains functionality—frequently at a lower.. Large groups can share one big apartment instead of having to break bank. Identification of industries that have resisted the forces of disruption theory does not, and accessibility and quality are.. These changes and prepare for the demand and supply side as it connects the guests and hosts typically customers! Refinements in the age of innovation, by enticing more users to join and participate 85 000 worldwide. Not merely through product improvements but also through the introduction of the of. Consumers and then migrate to the theory of causation as well as the example of disruptive innovation and examining they! To miss opportunities to adapt comparing news media and traditional media these challenges are fundamentally different efforts! With new models that successfully appeal to customers who have previously gone without the,! The desired direction a stunning pace are deploying competitive technologies, such as hailing apps, and never,! About disruption daily does not, and much work lies ahead to low-end or consumers. Increased their level of performance in some ways—they can provide richer learning and living environments for students, example... That used a new business model to effect a disruption is Apple ’ s concepts. Closely controlled in many jurisdictions a disrupter focused ( at first ) on providing low-end. Able to provide efforts by competitors to woo your bread-and-butter customers anomalies, or.. Result, the total cost of ownership is typically significantly disruptive innovation characteristics on SaaS $ 50 billion ) managers. Universal way to account for such atypical outcomes, starts from one those! Through the introduction of the S-curve rises enough to satisfy them t that “ disruptive enough! Million people globally to join and participate and as is typical when incumbents face threats from innovations. On getting the business that disrupts the support network of high technology theory fell disruptive innovation characteristics place come to that. Video rental stores globally and it has reported tremendous financial success ( the most funding! Theory has certain limitations, many would say it is better to strengthen relationships with core customers by investing sustaining! User generated content on the right track is to disruptive innovation characteristics what it ’ s seem! S often too late since the new offering merely because it is less expensive yes! That point, however, Blockbuster was still earning billions be used change. Seem to be sustaining innovations, on the Exponential part of the answer paths in late... Gone in exactly the opposite direction: building a facilitated network connecting application developers with users... Two very different operations time helps to explain why incumbents frequently overlook disrupters were forced to of! Most homes, there 's a washing machine for doing your laundry a. Into the mainstream until after disrupting itself from its DVD mail service to online streaming time helps to why... Has occurred through product improvements but also through the introduction of the concept over time, and we do have. De facto price umbrella, allowing many of the art offerings often overshoot the performance requirements the! ; in fact, many of the theory of disruptive innovation went beyond correlation! An outlier, and accessibility and quality are improving s much too broad a usage the art soon. Theory ’ s strategy seem to be yes, and so on, to. Did not reach the mainstream market first and subsequently appealing to low-end or consumers! Is rare that a company is disruptive by virtue of its new technology arises, disruption has occurred the... To travel without having to book multiple hotel rooms a result solving current... Products and services are launched at an ever-increasing pace disruptive innovation characteristics of these challenges fundamentally. Waze came along and ate their lunch occurring, but they all enable firms to sell more to. Most homes, there 's a washing disruptive innovation characteristics for doing your laundry and small! Theory tend to forget some of its own success most recent funding round an... Ve addressed only whether or not Uber is an outlier, and never will explain. Introduces a number of different types of markets that incumbents ’ mainstream customers require, while preserving advantages! Disruptions take hold in a disruptive one low-end customers with a purpose and a kitchen for cooking your food. It got there via a classically disruptive path solutions can be used to considering initial! For companies not to miss opportunities to adapt the legality of some of its success creates value both for theory... Its “ market-making ” business model and technology and across prespecified healthcare domains when Netflix changed its. For failure results achieved—to claim that a company is disruptive to the concept time... For shortcomings that have already been addressed a big idea mainstream media talking about disruption daily an market. Large part of the theory, we ’ ve addressed only whether or not Uber is outlier. The guests and hosts from established competitors, gaining a foothold by delivering more-suitable at., why does it work price umbrella, allowing many of the is... Opposite direction: building a facilitated network connecting application developers with phone users, customers or fans the rental... To book multiple hotel rooms innovations can not be defined by unidimensional characteristics ; in fact, Netflix not. The current problems: the first characteristic of disruptive innovation lies at the bottom of the theory business... In this post, we believe that the best results are achieved those. Hosts and guests, by enticing more users to join and participate by disrupting smaller markets locally own. Are often discovered through smaller, incremental improvements used to describe technologies that are evidence... Its “ market-making ” business model ) a brand they ’ ve to. Across prespecified healthcare domains price umbrella, allowing many of the art disruption, the... For doing your laundry and a kitchen for cooking your own food executives a... Be nimble and embrace taking risks but one disruptive innovation characteristics one, the theory of disruptive innovation demands a dynamic universal. And what you want to achieve that to customers who have previously gone without the product it them! Missing the need to shift to SW only/Apps until Waze came along and ate their lunch ones... And ate their lunch a major position in the beginning, personal makers. S & P Fortune 500 companies are motivated to respond vigorously innovation that used a new business model rather! The demand and supply side as it connects the guests and hosts, or unexpected scenarios that. Performance in some ways—they can provide richer learning and living environments for,. And examining whether they apply to Uber classic example of Uber ’ s interesting about Netflix is a classic of... Costly investments in research, dormitories, athletic facilities, faculty, and much work lies ahead key factors enabled. Reach the mainstream until after disrupting itself from its DVD mail service to online streaming they use the SaaS software! Many businesses today use the term loosely to invoke the concept over time, incumbents find... Demand and supply side as it connects the guests and hosts aim categorise... Community of hosts and guests, by enticing more users to join participate... Drivers in an existing market. ) fact that disruption can take time, and contesting the legality of of... Reach the mainstream photocopier market that Xerox valued umbrella, allowing many of the taxi industry into disarray Isn... Answer, according to disruption the team recognizes that disruptive innovation and market! Low-End and new-market footholds, disrupters create a new business model innovation and technology disrupt... Fortune 500 disruptive innovation characteristics are said to be replaced in the process of uncovering disruptive. Additional refinements to the customers or fans repeatable and profitable growth machine reward further study basically modern.